M-4, M-16 and other rifles Part III: What can take their place?

One of the big knocks against the M-16/M-4 family is that it uses a system called “direct impingement” to cycle the weapon. Gas is tapped by a small hole under the front sight, directed via a stainless steel tube, and then strikes the bolt and bolt carrier directly. This causes carbon to build up rapidly and the weapon needs frequent cleaning and judicious use of lubrication. Most semi-automatic and automatic rifles use a piston system, where the gas instead strikes a piston that drives a rod connected to the bolt to cycle the weapon. While this reduces carbon buildup, it does mean more parts and weight.

XBradTC on why the Army is looking into an M-4 replacement. politics is one factor that delayed the M-4 replacement. Colt pitched a fit when the Army Times ran it’s story about the HK-416.

But now the Army is taking a look at retiring the black rifle. The potential replacements today are:

  1. The XM-8
  2. The HK-416
    , basically it’s just an M-16 with a gas piston instead of a gas tube.
  3. The FN SCAR
  4. M-4 like rifles made by the following: LWRC, Bushmaster and Barrett Firearms

    courtesy Barrett Firearms

    MODEL REC7 from Barrett Firearms

  5. Colt, how for years dragged their feet on gas pistons now has their Advanced Hybrid Carbine (AHC). It’s a Gas-Impingement/Gas Piston Hybrid Weapon. Their automatic rifle for the marines however is a gas-impingement weapon.
  6. Even Italy has a dog in the fight: the Beretta ARX-160 Carbine.

So who will win the marbles?

Vote and don’t forget to vote Nov 4th!

3 Responses to “M-4, M-16 and other rifles Part III: What can take their place?”

  1. Sturmgewehr M16…

    Sturmgewehr M16 – A2

    Das Sturmgewehr M16 ist eines der verbreitesten Sturmgewehre der Welt und vor allem bei den amerikanischen Streitkräften im Einsatz….

  2. […] M-16: the FN SCAR makes it’s debut One of the most popular posts here is my take on the M-16 debate. The FN SCAR (SOF Combat Assault Rifle) has been issued to the 1st Battalion, 75th Ranger Regiment. […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: